Drivers who value long-lasting performance often debate between the Pirelli Scorpion AS Plus 3 and the Michelin Defender 2. Both tires represent premium craftsmanship, with a focus on delivering year-round reliability, comfort, and tread life.

The Pirelli Scorpion AS Plus 3 caters to crossovers and SUVs, offering a balance of traction, quiet rides, and durability in diverse weather. Michelin Defender 2 steps up with a reputation for outstanding mileage, impressive fuel efficiency, and a confident grip in wet and dry conditions.

Each model serves drivers with different priorities, from smooth highway commutes to extended treadwear for demanding daily use. Selecting the right option depends on how much emphasis you place on comfort, handling precision, or long-term value

A closer look at both tires highlights their unique strengths and helps determine which delivers the best overall performance for your driving needs.

Pirelli Scorpion AS Plus 3 vs Michelin Defender 2

Drivers today expect more from their tires. Safety, comfort, and durability must come together in one package.

Two names that stand out in the all-season touring category are the Pirelli Scorpion AS Plus 3 and the Michelin Defender 2. Both are trusted, but each delivers its strengths in different ways. Let’s explore them in detail.

Pirelli Scorpion All Season Plus 3

 

Product Details

• Brand: Pirelli

• Size: 225/65R17 102H

• Section Width: 225 mm

• Load Capacity: 1874 lbs

• Tread Depth: 12/32″

• Tread Type: Asymmetrical

• Max Pressure: 44 PSI

• Rim Width: 17 inches

• Tire Diameter: 28.5 inches

• Speed Rating: H

Designed for CUVs, SUVs, and light trucks, the Scorpion AS Plus 3 blends tread life with year-round confidence.

Features

• Long-lasting tread compound built for extra miles.

• Full-depth sipes that maintain grip even as the tire wears down.

• 3D sipe technology enhances cornering and stability in wet or dry conditions.

• Broad contact patch distributes weight evenly, reducing uneven wear.

• Asymmetrical tread pattern balances comfort, handling, and traction.

What is the good?

The deep 12/32″ tread gives a strong start with plenty of biting edges. The sipe system helps maintain traction even after thousands of miles. Comfort is a highlight – the tire absorbs road imperfections well, which is important for larger SUVs and crossovers.

On highways, the tire runs quietly, making long trips more relaxing. Handling in rain is reliable. The grooves channel water out efficiently, so hydroplaning is less likely.

Braking distance in wet and dry conditions is shorter than many mid-range competitors. It also fits a wide variety of popular vehicles, from Honda CR-V and Toyota RAV4 to Ford F-150 and Jeep Cherokee.

What is the bad?

This tire is not a true winter tire. In light snow it works fine, but in heavy snow or icy conditions, grip weakens. Drivers in northern climates will need a dedicated winter tire.

Handling feels softer than Michelin, so sporty drivers may find the steering less precise. Its tread life is good but not as long as Michelin’s Defender 2.

Overall Opinion

The Pirelli Scorpion AS Plus 3 is a solid all-rounder. It’s best for drivers who want a mix of comfort, traction, and decent mileage without paying a premium price. Ideal for family SUVs and crossovers in regions with mild winters.

MICHELIN Defender2 All-Season Tire

 

Product Details

• Brand: Michelin

• Size: 225/50R17 98H XL

• Section Width: 225 mm

• Load Capacity: 1653 lbs

• Tread Depth: 10.5/32″

• Tread Type: Symmetrical

• Max Pressure: 50 PSI

• Rim Width: 8 inches

• Tire Diameter: 25.9 inches

• Speed Rating: H

The Defender 2 is Michelin’s newest long-life all-season tire. It combines safety and comfort while being engineered to outlast many competitors.

Features

• Longest-lasting Michelin all-season tire.

• Locking 3D sipes create hundreds of biting edges for grip.

• Proven to last up to 25,000 miles longer than top rivals.

• Symmetrical tread ensures even wear over time.

• Backed by 80,000-mile treadwear warranty and 6-year limited warranty.

What is the good?

Longevity is its strongest advantage. Michelin designed the Defender 2 for drivers who want maximum miles from their investment. Many users report smoother performance even at higher mileage.

Wet braking is excellent. The tire’s compound and siping allow shorter stopping distances compared to most competitors, which makes it safer during sudden stops.

Dry handling feels more precise than Pirelli’s Scorpion AS Plus 3. Noise levels are low, with the tire staying quiet even at highway speeds. Comfort is consistent, with less vibration on uneven roads.

What is the bad?

The cost is high. Michelin demands more upfront, though the long tread life may balance it over time. While it handles light snow, it still lacks the bite of a dedicated winter tire. Some drivers may also find it less exciting to drive, since the focus is durability rather than sporty handling.

Overall Opinion

The Michelin Defender 2 is built for long-term value. It gives drivers confidence in both dry and wet roads, while lasting tens of thousands of miles longer than many rivals. Best for people who want peace of mind, long mileage, and safety in most conditions.

Detailed Comparison for

Both tires are strong options, but their strengths differ. The Pirelli Scorpion AS Plus 3 leans toward comfort and everyday versatility. With its deep tread and asymmetrical design, it suits SUVs and crossovers that carry families or cargo.

It delivers smooth rides and balanced handling but does not last as long as Michelin. The Michelin Defender 2 prioritizes longevity and safety.

It performs better in wet braking and provides a more precise steering feel. Its symmetrical tread ensures even wear, and its 80,000-mile warranty is among the best in the industry.

In terms of fuel efficiency, Michelin may have a slight edge because of its optimized tread compound. Pirelli, with its deeper tread, may generate a little more rolling resistance in early miles.

Noise levels are low in both, though Michelin stays quieter as it wears. Climate performance also differs. Pirelli handles rain and mild snow well but struggles in harsher winters.

Michelin does a little better in light snow but is also not meant for severe winter. For icy or deep-snow regions, winter tires are still necessary.

FAQs

Which tire lasts longer?
Michelin Defender 2. It often outlasts Pirelli by 10,000 to 20,000 miles.

Which tire is more affordable?
Pirelli Scorpion AS Plus 3 costs less upfront.

Which tire is better for SUVs?
Pirelli fits more SUV and crossover sizes, making it a natural choice for larger vehicles.

Which tire is safer in wet braking?
Michelin Defender 2 has better stopping distances in rain.

Do both tires work in snow?
Yes, for light snow only. Neither is good for deep snow or ice.

Conclusion

Both the Pirelli Scorpion AS Plus 3 and the Michelin Defender 2 are strong all-season tires, but they suit different drivers.

Pirelli is about comfort, balance, and value for SUV and crossover owners. Michelin focuses on maximum tread life, safety, and dependability.

Drivers who want a smooth ride at a lower cost can go with Pirelli Scorpion AS Plus 3. Those who value durability and stronger wet braking should invest in Michelin Defender 2.